The Mince Pie Club
Sixteen supermarket mince pies. Fifteen blind tastings. One pie leaves with the crown. The panel eats its way to the final every week between now and Christmas.
- Season
- 2026
- Next tasting
- Thu 19 Nov · Aldi Holly Lane vs. Morrisons Bakery
- Format
- Straight knockout · panel average out of 10
Wall chart
Round of 16
17 SepFull time
Tesco Classic7.5
Sainsbury's Classic8.0
24 SepFull time
M&S Collection9.0
Waitrose No.15.0
01 OctFull time
Aldi Holly Lane9.0
Lidl Favorina4.0
08 OctFull time
Asda Deep Filled5.0
Morrisons Bakery7.0
15 OctFull time
Aldi Specially Selected7.9
Lidl Deluxe8.0
22 OctFull time
Tesco Finest8.0
Sainsbury's Taste the Difference6.0
29 OctFull time
Asda Extra Special9.0
Morrisons The Best5.0
05 NovFull time
M&S Festive Twist9.0
Waitrose Twist5.0
Quarter-finals
12 NovFull time
Sainsbury's Classic
M&S Collection
19 NovUp next
Aldi Holly Lane
Morrisons Bakery
26 Nov
Lidl Deluxe
Tesco Finest
03 Dec
Asda Extra Special
M&S Festive Twist
Semi-finals
10 Dec
M&S Collection
Winner QF 2
10 Dec
Winner QF 3
Winner QF 4
Final
17 Dec
Winner SF 1
Winner SF 2
Champion
To be crowned
Runner-up ————
Results
Panel average out of 10
DateTieRoundScore
12 NovSainsbury's Classicvs.M&S CollectionQuarter-finalsM&S Collection wins
05 NovM&S Festive Twistvs.Waitrose TwistRound of 169.0 – 5.0
29 OctAsda Extra Specialvs.Morrisons The BestRound of 169.0 – 5.0
22 OctTesco Finestvs.Sainsbury's Taste the DifferenceRound of 168.0 – 6.0
15 OctAldi Specially Selectedvs.Lidl DeluxeRound of 167.9 – 8.0
08 OctAsda Deep Filledvs.Morrisons BakeryRound of 165.0 – 7.0
01 OctAldi Holly Lanevs.Lidl FavorinaRound of 169.0 – 4.0
24 SepM&S Collectionvs.Waitrose No.1Round of 169.0 – 5.0
17 SepTesco Classicvs.Sainsbury's ClassicRound of 167.5 – 8.0
The pie was just simply the best - insert pie pun here